Roofing materials and costs
Composite Shingles vs Asphalt

Last updated November 21, 2026 · Method · Corrections
Composition shingles are asphalt shingles. Molded composite shingles can look like slate or wood.
Sections5
If a bid says composite, ask what the shingle is made of. Then compare the full price and check the ratings for the roof in each bid.
What the shingles are made of
The Asphalt Roofing Manufacturers Association guide describes a fiberglass mat coated with asphalt that contains fine mineral filler. Colored grit on the face gives the shingle its look and shields the asphalt from the sun. The mat is the layer that holds the shingle together.
Three-tab asphalt has cutouts that form three tabs. With architectural asphalt, the maker bonds layers to give the roof more depth. The same trade guide notes that some designer asphalt lines copy the look of wood or slate. A slate pattern on a sample board can still be asphalt.
An engineering evaluation report dated March 6, 2025 shows how one molded line uses a blend of plastics to make slate-look and shake-look shingles. A shake is a roof piece with the look of split wood. The roofing materials guide puts both looks alongside real slate and cedar.
What wind, hail and fire ratings tell you
- For coastal wind, start with the address. Ask the local building department which wind rules apply. Then get the wind record for the exact covering and its fasteners. The Building America asphalt guide explains why coastal homes in high-wind areas may need stronger attachment. For the products it covers, the engineering report shows how the allowed setup can change with roof height or the building's exposure, as well as the fasteners used.
- Check how the edges are held down. Ask how the quote deals with the eaves and the sloping edges. The Building America guide shows how an asphalt starter strip bonds to the first row of shingles to help resist wind and rain. For a molded product, ask how the first row is held down and look for that detail in the product drawings.
- For hail, write down the test and impact class. The asphalt trade guide explains how UL 2218 ranks asphalt shingles in an impact test. The Florida report also lists that test for the molded products it covers. If the bid says “impact resistant,” ask for the record that ties the rating to the exact shingle. The shingle impact ratings guide explains what those classes mean.
- For fire, check the whole roof build. The Florida report shows that the fire class can depend on how the roof is built, including what goes under the shingles. Ask for the listing that matches the layers in your quote. A label for one setup cannot settle the rating for a different deck or base layer.
Slope and deck fit
- Get the pitch of each section. Pitch is how much the roof rises over a set run. The December 2022 Building America guide puts the minimum for asphalt shingles at 2:12, or two inches of rise for every foot of run. The guide calls for double underlayment in its low-slope asphalt range from 2:12 up to 4:12. Underlayment is the sheet between the deck and the shingles.
- Match the molded product to the actual deck. Look for the pitch, deck material and base sheet in the report for the model in the bid. If the deck cannot be seen from below, make the bid say how the roofer will identify it once the old covering comes off. Look for the row that matches both the deck and the pitch.
- Mark where the coverings meet. Have the quote name the material on each slope and show the joint between them. This gives you a way to check whether both bids include work along that whole joint or stop short of it.
Service life and repair
- Treat age as a clue. A 2007 National Association of Home Builders study, reprinted by the Port of Seattle, gave about 20 years for asphalt shingles. The authors drew on a U.S. survey of manufacturers, trade groups and researchers. Use that estimate to put an older roof in context. The asphalt roof lifespan guide shows how to weigh age alongside what is happening on the roof.
- Ask for a service record for the molded shingle. Get the model name and the dates of past jobs in a climate like yours. Ask what repairs those roofs have needed. No service-life figure is published for molded composite shingles as a group. A test result for wind or hail cannot tell you how many years a roof will serve.
- Save what you would need for a patch. Keep the bill and a photo of the label showing the color. Ask if you can keep spare pieces from your job. Find out how the roofer would lift a damaged piece out of the finished roof. Save the written product and labor terms to see who pays for a replacement piece and who pays to put it in.
How to compare installed quotes
No national installed price for these two shingle types on the same job scope is published. Ask for separate prices for the complete work at your address.
- Compare the same roof area. Ask both roofers to show the same measured roof planes, including any porch or garage in the job. Ask for the installed area on its own line. Keep the amount they plan to buy on a different line so extra pieces for cuts and spares do not look like extra roof area.
- Price the work under the shingles. Ask what the bid includes for tear-off and haul-away, the base sheet under the shingles, and the flashing that guides water away from walls or pipes. Get the deck repair rate and the unit it uses, such as per sheet. If the old deck is hidden, ask how the roofer will show what needs to come out before charging for it.
- Check what will stay in place. Have each bid itemize the work at the valleys, where roof slopes meet. Ask how work around a chimney or skylight is priced and whether the vents will stay or get replaced. Ask for the cost of new metal where one quote includes it and the other keeps what is there.
- Compare totals and view full samples. Once you have complete bids, write down what you would pay for each finished roof. If the molded roof costs more, decide if the look and the other features in that bid are worth the gap to you. View a board with several rows from ground level in daylight. The National Park Service describes multicolored and graduated slate patterns. Compare how the rows line up and how the edges look.
Quick answers
Is rubberized asphalt a synthetic composite shingle?
It is still an asphalt shingle. In a rubberized asphalt shingle, the maker adds a rubber-like polymer to the asphalt. Look for the base material on the product sheet. The word polymer on its own can refer to an additive or to the material the piece is molded from.
Does a dark shingle always absorb more heat than a light one?
Color alone does not tell you how much sun a product reflects. Some asphalt shingles have granules made to reflect more sunlight. Check the Cool Roof Rating Council's solar reflectance ratings for the exact products you want to compare.
Can I put a slate-look roof on a historic house?
First find out whether the existing roof is real slate and whether local rules govern changes. The National Park Service advises keeping and repairing historic slate when you can. It advises against artificial mineral-fiber slate for restoration work.
Do hip and ridge pieces count in the shingle order?
Include them in the order. They cover the raised joints where roof planes meet. Ask for a separate count for these pieces so you can tell what comes with the field shingles. Check that the caps belong to the system named on the bid.