Roof replacement project
Synthetic Underlayment vs Felt

Last updated November 19, 2026 · Method · Corrections
Asphalt-saturated felt and polymeric synthetic sheets both serve as steep-slope underlayment when the product matches the ASTM standard your code names. The Goodhue County, Minnesota residential roofing handout (citing R905.1.1) requires 15-pound felt layers on 2:12 to 4:12 shingle slopes. The two families differ in how they hold and release moisture.
Sections6
Asphalt-saturated felt and polymeric synthetic sheets both work as steep-slope underlayment when the chosen product matches the ASTM standard your adopted code accepts. The Goodhue County, Minnesota residential roofing handout (citing R905.1.1) spells out 15-pound felt layers by shingle roof slope. The two families handle trapped moisture differently beneath the covering.
How the two families differ
Steep-slope jobs often compare organic felt (sometimes called tar paper) with woven or spun polymer sheets. They are not interchangeable labels on the same roll.
| Family | Typical makeup | Standards body label |
|---|---|---|
| Asphalt-saturated felt | Organic fiber mat saturated with asphalt | ASTM D226 Type I (No. 15) or Type II (No. 30); ASTM D4869 for underlayment felt |
| Polymeric synthetic sheet | Mechanically attached polymer membrane | ASTM D8257 for steep-slope polymeric underlayment |
Scroll for more →
The ASTM D226 scope names Type I and Type II asphalt-saturated organic felts for use as underlayment in steep-slope roofing systems. The ASTM D4869 scope covers asphalt-saturated organic felt sold as steep-slope underlayment with physical tests for tear, pliability, and liquid water transmission. ASTM Committee D08.02 lists D8257 for mechanically attached polymeric roof underlayment used on steep slopes.
The roof underlayment guide walks through self-adhering ice-barrier sheets and how each layer fits under shingles, metal, or tile. The roof replacement process guide shows where underlayment sits in a full tear-off.
Building code acceptance
One published example is the Goodhue County, Minnesota residential roofing handout (Minnesota residential code context), which quotes section R905.1.1 for underlayment on shingle roofs:
- For roof slopes from 2:12 up to 4:12, apply two layers of 15-pound felt in shingle fashion, beginning with a 19-inch starter strip at the eave.
- For slopes of 4:12 and greater, apply one layer of 15-pound felt with stated end and side laps.
- Fasten each sheet enough to hold it in place until the covering is installed.
That example shows what one Minnesota county requires: the written rule names 15-pound felt layers and lap dimensions. A synthetic quote must show which standard-backed product the jurisdiction allows instead of or alongside those felt layers. The local building department names the adopted code edition and any listing that approves polymeric sheets.
Moisture, breathability, and drying
Installers sometimes choose felt because they expect moisture vapor to pass through or leave the assembly. Synthetic marketing often stresses watertightness and long dry-in time. The useful comparison is how each product wets and dries under your actual covering, not a single breathability score.
An ASTM International research summary on underlayment performance states that newer underlayment products show significant moisture retention and permeability differences compared with traditional ASTM D226 Type I and Type II felts. That summary also reports major differences in wetting and drying rates that are both product and underlayment dependent.
Organic felt under ASTM D4869 is produced principally from organic fibers in an asphalt-saturated mat. That structure can hold moisture differently from a mechanically attached polymeric sheet under ASTM D8257.
When trapped moisture is the main worry, read what is included in roof replacement with the underlayment line filled in. Ask whether the quote names a breathable or nonwoven synthetic, the stated permeance class on the data sheet, and how long the sheet may remain exposed.
Exposure time and standard tests
Organic underlayment felt under ASTM D4869 is tested for dimensional stability after outdoor exposure to sun, rain, frost, and dew.
Wind uplift and fastener pull-through also differ by sheet stiffness. ASTM D4869 lists breaking strength and tear strength for organic felt. A contractor should match cap nails or staples to the sheet listed on the permit, not reuse a felt pattern on a stiffer polymer without checking the manual.
Coverage and installation steps
Use these steps to compare bids without mixing product classes:
- Record each roof plane slope and the code section the contractor cites for underlayment.
- Ask for the product name, ASTM standard, and roll width that sets the lap math.
- List fasteners, cap nails, or adhesive strips required by that product's installation manual.
- Match ice-barrier width at eaves and valleys to the same code handout or amended rule.
- Keep tear-off, deck repair, and disposal as separate lines from the underlayment roll cost.
No qualifying government or standards body publishes a national installed-price gap between felt and synthetic underlayment. Per-roll area and weight vary by product.
For tile roofs that must be lifted to reach the sheet, see tile roof underlayment replacement cost. Felt and synthetic prices there still need the tile-handling scope beside them.
Choosing for your replacement quote
Neither family wins on name alone. The correct sheet is the one the covering manufacturer and the adopted code accept for your slope, climate, and ventilation path.
Ask the contractor to leave the product data sheets with the proposal. Check that the listed standard matches the material on the truck. When a bid says only roofing felt, ask whether it means No. 15 organic felt, a heavier No. 30 layer, or a synthetic sheet.
If the assembly includes metal panels, plan underlayment as part of condensation control above the deck. The Department of Energy metal roof guide calls for a continuous underlayment to protect sheathing where condensation can form on the underside in cold or cooling conditions. If the assembly is asphalt shingles on a cold-climate eave, coordinate any self-adhered ice barrier with the underlayment laps. Those details belong in the same written scope.
Keep the underlayment product label on the proposal even when the outer look of the rolls is similar. A felt-compatible specification sheet should not be assumed to approve a D8257 polymeric sheet without a named substitution on the permit or inspection record.
When you review the final invoice, confirm the installed brand matches the quoted ASTM class. Inspection photos of laps at valleys and penetrations help show that the crew followed the stated standard instead of swapping an unlisted house wrap or thinner felt off the truck.
On re-roofs, note whether old felt was fully removed or left as an extra layer under new synthetic. Extra layers can change drying paths and may conflict with the covering maker's maximum stack-up. Mark removal scope as included, partial, or unknown before you compare felt-only and synthetic bids.
Quick answers
Does tar paper still meet building codes?
The Goodhue County, Minnesota residential roofing handout (citing R905.1.1) requires two layers of 15-pound felt on shingle roofs from 2:12 to 4:12, with one layer and stated laps on 4:12 and steeper slopes. Ask the local building department which code edition applies to your address and whether an ASTM-listed synthetic underlayment is an allowed alternate.
Is synthetic underlayment more breathable than felt?
ASTM research reports major wetting and drying differences between traditional D226 felts and newer underlayment products. Permeability varies by exact product. Match the sheet to the covering maker's assembly instead of assuming one family always breathes more.
Can synthetic underlayment replace 15-pound felt?
Only when the written scope names a product that meets the standard your jurisdiction accepts for that roof type and slope. A polymeric sheet listed under ASTM D8257 is a different product class than organic felt under ASTM D226 or D4869.
Which underlayment is better under metal roofing?
Use a continuous underlayment where condensation can form under metal roofing, and name the exact product in the quote. Match the sheet to the metal system's installation manual rather than felt lap rules from a shingle handout.
How long can underlayment stay exposed before shingles go on?
ASTM D4869 tests organic felt left exposed to sun, rain, frost and dew for two weeks after application; check the product sheet for the window that applies to your sheet.